Since 1932, Elmer's Brighton Garage has been a family-owned business serving our community for over 20 years. Our mission is to deliver full-service, top-quality auto repair at fair and competitive prices while offering value-added services. We partner with our customers, employees, and community to achieve sustainable growth and consistent annual profitability. Our priority is for every customer to leave completely satisfied.

Auto Electrical

Elmer's Brighton Garage provides the best electrical auto service in Rochester, hands down.

Heating & Air Conditioner Repair

For the best cooling and heating auto repair service in Rochester, trust Elmer's Brighton Garage.

Engine Auto Service

When that check engine light comes on, it’s hard not to feel annoyed or even worried.

Maintenance & Auto Service

It’s a fact: regular, quality maintenance extends the life of your vehicle. It also gives you the peace of mind you need.

Exhaust Service

If you’re concerned about passing emissions or you already know your exhaust system isn’t what it should be, visit Elmer's Brighton Garage in Rochester.

The Absolute Best Car Service in Rochester, NY

Elmer's Brighton Garage

What sets Elmer's Brighton Garage apart from all of the others in Rochester, NY?

Quality Service

We use the latest diagnostic equipment and high-quality parts to ensure your vehicle is repaired to the highest standards.

Experienced and Certified Technicians

Our technicians are highly skilled and certified professionals with years of experience in the auto repair industry. They have the expertise to diagnose and repair any problem your vehicle may have.

Customer Satisfaction

Our goal is to exceed your expectations and ensure your complete satisfaction with every visit.

Our Customer Reviews

Repeat

Best auto service you are going to find

Scott S.

2015 Chevrolet – 4/16/2026

Verified Customer

Significant Repairs In A Day

Elmer’s said they could switch the snow tires off my wife’s minivan, and replace the front struts. Once they got into it they discovered the front tie rods were loose/worn and the rear shocks … More also needed replacing. Oh, and it needed to be inspected as well. They got everything done before 5pm, and the car is riding a lot smoother. I think the price was reasonable for the everything that was fixed. Less

Mark W.

2014 Honda – 4/15/2026

Verified Customer

Stellar

Always the best of service.

Verified Customer

2022 Subaru – 4/15/2026

Verified Customer

Thank you Elmers!

Had to get multiple things done here. Went in for one problem, the team found and took care of other problems that popped up. They were very communicative and amiable. Good people to do business … More with! Less

Tatum O.

2007 Toyota – 4/14/2026

Verified Customer

Always excellent!

Had a nail in my tire and was loosing air. AAA put air in it and I called Elmer’s Garage. On a busy Friday, they fit me in on super short notice. They fixed the tire and noticed my NYS inspection … More was about to expire – asked me if I wanted to get that done too.Said absolutely! So had tire fixed and can cross the inspection off my list. Really appreciated that ! Less

FRANCES T.

2024 Nissan – 4/10/2026

Verified Customer

Recently Serviced Vehicles

Contact Us Today for an Auto Repair Estimate

Our friendly and knowledgeable staff is always happy to answer any questions you may have and will keep you informed throughout the entire repair process. So why pick us for all your Rochester auto repair needs? The answer is simple: expertise, customer service, affordability, convenience, and quality. Contact us today to schedule your appointment and experience the difference for yourself.

Hours

Mon-Fri : 7am-6pm
Sat-Sun : Closed

Address

Elmer's Brighton Garage
1848 Monroe Ave
Rochester, NY 14618-1922

Welcome to
Elmer's Brighton Garage

Auto Electrical

Heating & Air Conditioner Repair

Engine Auto Service

Maintenance & Auto Service

Exhaust Service

Complete & Reliable Automotive Service & Repair

Auto Repair Estimates In Rochester