Reviews

At Elmer's Brighton Garage we provide each of our customers with reliable, trustworthy car service. We know that each time we work on your car our reputation in the community is on the line, and we act accordingly. This is why we have such loyal, enthusiastic customers! Let our auto repair professionals show you that you can trust Elmer's Brighton Garage.

FT
FRANCES T.
2024 Nissan – 4/10/2026
Verified Customer
Always excellent!
Had a nail in my tire and was loosing air. AAA put air in it and I called Elmer’s Garage. On a busy Friday, they fit me in on super short notice. They fixed the tire and noticed my NYS inspection More was about to expire – asked me if I wanted to get that done too.Said absolutely! So had tire fixed and can cross the inspection off my list. Really appreciated that ! Less
JN
Jason N.
2017 Toyota – 4/10/2026
Verified Customer
Spoke with Misty. She said the business has always been able to get her in on emergency. They always call and ask to begin doing work before starting, especially on costly fixes. Misty has gone More for years and recommends the business frequently. Less
VC
Verified Customer
2021 Acura – 4/8/2026
Verified Customer
Always good service
Everyone is very professional and the service is excellent.
VC
Verified Customer
2007 Honda – 4/8/2026
Verified Customer
Always a good experience
Great friendly staff, excellent service at a fair price and it’s a neighborhood small business. The 3 dogs are just icing on the cake!
KS
Kevin S.
2023 Honda – 4/8/2026
Verified Customer
Over 25 years of great service.
Elmers has provided excellent service on several cars my family has had over the years. I highly recommend them.

Car Service You Can Trust